NBC's 2025 Crime Show Gets Strong Rotten Tomatoes Audience Score After Mixed Reviews From Critics

One of the Big Three TV networks in the US, NBC has long been one of the leading sources of entertainment, and its slate of crime shows has been attracting viewers for decades. Shows like Law & Order: SUV,Chicago P.D., and Homicide: Life On the Streets have helped establish the network as one of the leading channels for those looking to get their crime and mystery fix.

What's more, long-running successful crime thrillers, such as shows like The Blacklist and Blindspot, have helped to define NBC as one of the go-to networks for the genre. This has led to the development of newer crime dramas, such as The Hunting Party, which is currently airing and has been positively reviewed by audiences on Rotten Tomatoes despite being critically panned. This is not the only new NBC crime drama to post encouraging ratings, with another 2025 show enjoying a positive audience reaction on the site.

Grosse Pointe Garden Society Is Highly-Rated on Rotten Tomatoes

The Crime-Drama Seems To Be Capturing Viewers' Imaginations

Created by Jenna Bans and Bill Krebs and starring Melissa Fumero, Aja Naomi King, Ben Rappaport, and Nancy Travis, Grosse Pointe Garden Society dropped on NBC on February 23 and has just aired its pilot episode. The show follows four members of a local gardening club who become embroiled in a scandalous murder in an affluent Detroit suburb. The show's pilot episode, directed by Maggie Kiley, attracted more than 1.7 million viewers.

Ben Rappaport, Aja Naomi King and AnnaSophia Robb in Grosse Pointe Garden Society

Grosse Pointe Garden Society Review: Melissa Fumero Steals The Show, But I Wanted More From NBC's Soapy Fun Dramedy

NBC's Grosse Pointe Garden Society feels more familiar than fresh, ultimately lacking a key spark even though it's an overall entertaining watch.

Posts1

Now, Grosse Pointe Garden Societyhas racked up an audience score of 89% on Rotten Tomatoes, while the critical score is 62%. The scores will inevitably fluctuate as more reviews drop. However, signs are promising for the new show, especially since the series originally debuted with a poor score in the 30s when the first reviews arrived. ScreenRant's Rachel Labonte awarded the series a 6 out of 10 stars, noting the exceptional performance of Melissa Fumero, while the lack of chemistry and predictable twists were key issues.

Our Verdict On Grosse Pointe Garden Society

The Series Is A Smart, Quirky Offering In The Crime Genre

A smart, quirky, soapy dramedy, there is much to be excited about for the future of Grosse Pointe Garden Society, and its family-friendly, off-beat vibe could be one of the biggest reasons behind the show's audience interest. A strong cast, an intelligent mystery, affluent surroundings, and smart twists make this an effortlessly watchable show, which should satisfy those wanting a refreshingly unique NBC crime show. Viewers who grow weary of the over-saturation of TV procedurals will no doubt welcome Grosse Pointe Garden Society as a breath of fresh air.

Grosse Pointe Garden Society airs on Sundays at 10 pm on NBC and can be streamed exclusively on Peacock.